Unconfigured Ad

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mard
    Member
    • Jan 2010
    • 21

    #1

    MAQ vs BWA/SAMTools - differences in SNP calling algorithm?

    I was wondering if anyone has come across this before. Basically we’re getting SNPs that were identified using MAQ, and subsequently validated by Sanger sequencing, not being called by BWA/SAMTools on the same set of reads (same sequence.txt files) yet the BWA/SAMTools pileup shows that there is an alternate allele present at the SNP location.

    In the example below, for both BWA and MAQ a similar number of reads mapped over the SNP (134 for BWA and 130 for MAQ). The SAMTools pileup shows that there is an alternate allele present (T), yet no SNP is called. I thought that MAQ’s SNP caller and the SAMtools SNP caller used the same algorithm so I’m confused as to why the SNP was not called by SAMTools. It is not being filtered out by varFilter as adding the –p flag doesn’t identify it either.

    BWA + SAMtools pileup:
    C C 73 0 58 134 ,$,$,$,$,$,$TT,,,T.A..,,,,.t,,,,,,.T.T.......,,,..........t............,........TTTT........tttttt........ttt,tt.............TTt,,t,,,,t,,,t

    MAQ + MAQ’s SNP caller output:
    C Y 37 130 1.00 63 62 C 250 T

    MAQ Pileup:
    C 130 @......TT...A,,,....,.....,T,,,,T,,,,...,,,,,,,,,,t,,,,,,,,,,,,.,,,,,,,,TTT,,,,,,,,tttttt,,,,,,,,tttt.t,,,,,,,,,,,,,TTt.....t...t.t
  • kmcarr
    Senior Member
    • May 2008
    • 1181

    #2
    Did you run samtools.pl varFilter after samtools pileup? The varFilter has a maximum read depth cutoff parameter for SNP calling (-D). The default value is 100. With a read depth of 134 the SNP would be rejected.

    Comment

    • mard
      Member
      • Jan 2010
      • 21

      #3
      Thanks for the suggestion but I ran varFilter with a read depth cutoff of 1,000,000 so that can't be the reason. Also I ran varFilter with the -p option aswell which prints the SNPs that are filtered out by varFilter and that SNP does not make it into that file either.
      So for some reason it's not getting recognised as a SNP by SAMTools yet MAQ was able to call it.

      Comment

      Latest Articles

      Collapse

      • SEQadmin2
        Beyond CRISPR/Cas9: Understand, Choose, and Use the Right Genome Editing Tool
        by SEQadmin2



        CRISPR/Cas9 sparked the gene editing revolution for both research and therapeutics.1 But this system still showed severe issues that limited its applications. The most prominent were the heavy reliance on PAM sequences, delivery limitations, double-stranded breaks that prompt unintended edits and cell death, and editing inefficiency (both in targeting and in knock-in reliability).

        Despite this, “CRISPR helped turn genome editing from a specialized technique into
        ...
        07-31-2026, 11:01 AM
      • SEQadmin2
        Proteomic Platforms: How to Choose the Right Analytical Strategy to Improve Detection and Clinical Applications
        by SEQadmin2


        Proteomics platforms are evolving rapidly, with advances in mass spectrometry and affinity-based approaches expanding what researchers can detect and at what scale. As the field moves toward deeper proteome coverage and clinical applications, scientists face an increasingly complex landscape of tools. This article will explore how researchers are navigating these choices to find the right platform for their work.

        The systematic characterization of the human proteome has
        ...
        07-20-2026, 11:48 AM
      • SEQadmin2
        Advanced Sequencing Platforms Tackle Neuroscience’s Toughest Genomics Problems
        by SEQadmin2



        Genomics studies in neuroscience face a special challenge due to the brain’s complexity and scarcity of samples. Mapping changes in cell type and state using conventional next-generation sequencing methods remains challenging. Advances in technologies like single-cell sequencing, spatial transcriptomics, and long-read sequencing have opened the door to deeper studies of the brain and diseases like Alzheimer’s, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), and schizophrenia.
        ...
        07-09-2026, 11:10 AM

      ad_right_rmr

      Collapse

      News

      Collapse

      Topics Statistics Last Post
      Started by SEQadmin2, 07-31-2026, 02:55 AM
      0 responses
      19 views
      0 reactions
      Last Post SEQadmin2  
      Started by SEQadmin2, 07-24-2026, 12:17 PM
      0 responses
      16 views
      0 reactions
      Last Post SEQadmin2  
      Started by SEQadmin2, 07-23-2026, 11:41 AM
      0 responses
      16 views
      0 reactions
      Last Post SEQadmin2  
      Started by SEQadmin2, 07-20-2026, 11:10 AM
      0 responses
      26 views
      0 reactions
      Last Post SEQadmin2  
      Working...