Unconfigured Ad

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • drdna
    Member
    • May 2012
    • 76

    Newbler outputting garbage

    I am wondering if anyone else has seen the following problem: I am using RNAseq to identify viral sequences among transcripts from an infected plant. Assembly of a single chip of Ion Torrent data was taking far too long (> 1 week - that's a separate issue) so I decided to use BLAST to identify reads matching short pieces of reference sequence from the virus in question. The matching reads were then assembled with Newbler 2.8. Three contigs were produced, the largest of which was 678 bp in length, contained 3/4 of the reads going into the assembly (3,700/4,500) and was reported as having high quality (most bases were Phred 64). Problem is, none of the resulting contigs match the viral sequences used to identify the constituent reads. Nor do any of the constituent reads match the assembly!

    Most of the reads had very good matches to the reference (< 3 mismatches) and assembly with phrap (using reads generated with sffinfo) produced contigs with lower reported quality values but which DO match the viral references. Thus Newbler is outputting assemblies which it reports as high quality but which are, in fact, complete garbage.
    Last edited by drdna; 12-06-2012, 06:15 AM.
  • flxlex
    Moderator
    • Nov 2008
    • 412

    #2
    Maybe you are giving newbler too many reads? How many bases do you give, and how many do you expect in your contigs? In other words, that is the coverage in raw reads you feed into newbler?

    Comment

    • drdna
      Member
      • May 2012
      • 76

      #3
      Coverage is approx. 50-fold. - not overly high. Main problem is that the contigs produced have ZERO similarity to the input reads. I could understand it if too much coverage produced too many contigs, or redundancy in the assembly due to experimentally-induced errors but no similarity whatsoever?

      Comment

      • flxlex
        Moderator
        • Nov 2008
        • 412

        #4
        Well, then I don't know either. I'd stick to your phrap results...

        Comment

        • yaximik
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2011
          • 199

          #5
          Both gsMapper and gsAssembler v2.7 are buggy and 454 is either unable or have no will/resources to fix them. I gave up on 2.7 and get back to 2.5p1.

          Comment

          Latest Articles

          Collapse

          • GATTACAT
            Reply to Nine Things a Sample Prep Scientist Thinks About Before Sequencing
            by GATTACAT
            Love this - good data definitely starts from good input, and poor input can only give relatively poor data. I particularly like the mention of Nanodrop/absorbance based methods for quantification. It's such a toss up if you'll get an accurate reading or what amounts to a randomly generated number, and a lot of library/sequencing related issues can be traced back to poor quant.
            07-01-2026, 11:43 AM
          • SEQadmin2
            Nine Things a Sample Prep Scientist Thinks About Before Sequencing
            by SEQadmin2


            I’m not a sequencing expert. I’m a purification scientist who uses NGS to evaluate workflows my group develops. With this perspective, we think about the sample first and the NGS workflow second. The sequencer is an exceptionally honest reporter, but it can only report on what you give it, so whether you get clean, interpretable data from an NGS workflow is largely determined before you begin.

            Here are nine questions we think about, in roughly the order they matter, before...
            06-18-2026, 07:11 AM

          ad_right_rmr

          Collapse

          News

          Collapse

          Topics Statistics Last Post
          Started by SEQadmin2, Yesterday, 11:08 AM
          0 responses
          7 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post SEQadmin2  
          Started by SEQadmin2, 06-30-2026, 05:37 AM
          0 responses
          11 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post SEQadmin2  
          Started by SEQadmin2, 06-26-2026, 11:10 AM
          0 responses
          20 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post SEQadmin2  
          Started by SEQadmin2, 06-17-2026, 06:09 AM
          0 responses
          54 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post SEQadmin2  
          Working...