[marcowanger]

Added a draft of wiki paper describing the SEQanswers community.

2 purposes.

(1) avoid self-plagiarism, (2) give insights for the writing

[robs]

I shifted a couple of things around and added some of the points into the text that were listed above. I think the text is getting in good shape, the only thing we still need is the figure and a few more stats.

This means: ECO, we need your help with the SQLdump. :-)

We might be over the word limit, but we can trim down the letter when we have added everything we want. (It will be easier to eliminate the weaker parts and select the most important ones.)

[adaptivegenome]

This means: ECO, we need your help with the SQLdump. :-)

I have this. Email me and I can share it with you.

[bioinfosm]

got really tied up for the past couple months, but this is very interesting, and can look to contribute.

I will start with scrolling through the thread, but feel free to PM me with any specifics..

[robs]

I added two figures to the gdoc and would like to get your comments and suggestions.

How is the tag cloud coming along?

[robs]

To save you the search for the gdoc link:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1.../edit?hl=en_US

[marcowanger]

Hi robs, great work. figure 1 is super nice, i see the new discussion(i suppose it means a thread?) still get steady increases after these years. While there are a slight drop /steady trend in the number of posts per month. Hey, on second thought I think the drop is due to bad curve fitting, the overall trend is still increasing. The rapid dropping in time between questions and answers support such argument. Obviously when ppl ask a question, normally they open a new post and thus the increase of new discussion.

For figure 2, the raw data points for time between Q&A looks a bit messy. Should we hide them?

[marcowanger]

Robs, remember to keep the data file and the scripts for graph generation. We still dont know if we have to change the color scheme or anything to suit journal's requirement. Great graphs!

[marcowanger]

Regarding the tag cloud, I think genericforms are having it done soon. Because there are already 2-3 figures potentially useful, I rather focus on the text. Just to avoid duplication of effort. Frankly, can we use all figures? Is there any #figures limitation? I think all these three would be worthwhile to be published. Thank you again robs!

[andreas.sjodin]

I like the first figure too. The points should probably go away in second figure to make it less messy.

[robs]

Thanks for the comments.

I think, we can only add one figure for the letter (not sure though). I will wait until the tag cloud is done and maybe we can put all together into one figure.

If you have more ideas of what data might be interesting to plot, let me know and I will do my best to get the graph done.

[marcowanger]

Thanks for the comments.

I think, we can only add one figure for the letter (not sure though). I will wait until the tag cloud is done and maybe we can put all together into one figure.

If you have more ideas of what data might be interesting to plot, let me know and I will do my best to get the graph done.

Having these three would be fine enough I think...

[marcowanger]

Thanks for the comments.

I think, we can only add one figure for the letter (not sure though). I will wait until the tag cloud is done and maybe we can put all together into one figure.

If you have more ideas of what data might be interesting to plot, let me know and I will do my best to get the graph done.

Just thinking overlaying the tag cloud into the second figure to replace the raw dots. What do you guys think?

[robs]

Just thinking overlaying the tag cloud into the second figure to replace the raw dots. What do you guys think?

If we want to make a single figure, then I would add the tag cloud data to the first one and ignore the second figure. We could keep the second figure for the longer version, if necessary. Or we can try to submit all figures that we will have at that point of submission and let them choose.

[marcowanger]

If we want to make a single figure, then I would add the tag cloud data to the first one and ignore the second figure. We could keep the second figure for the longer version, if necessary. Or we can try to submit all figures that we will have at that point of submission and let them choose.

Agree, it is good to have everything now.